Your Wisdom (Insight) check decides whether you can determine the true intentions of a creature, such as when searching out a lie or predicting someone's next move. Doing so involves gleaning clues from body language, speech habits, and changes in mannerisms.
I like the Insight skill. It's one my characters use frequently, to gain that extra edge in social encounters. It is however no surprise that, despite the fact that I envisage its use like a Sherlock-scanner of intent and micro-expression analysis, it is used about 95% of the time to tell if a NPC is lying to me.
This is not just the case with my own usage - as the PHB itself states, Insight is used to tell if a creature is lying. This turns the Insight skill from a DM perspective into a binary response roll: the player detects a lie or does not detect a lie. However, the way in which a DM conveys this information opens up space to interpretation.
For example, let's look at Critical Role's Matt Mercer. When responding to a player's Insight check, you can be expected to hear one of these two responses with reasonable frequency:
"They seem genuine." or "They're hard to read."
Both could theoretically be the same response to the same roll. Let's say that a player is trying to determine if the goblin telling them of hidden treasures in the troll cave is telling the truth. The player rolls Insight, and unfortunately their Insight check is lower than the goblin's Deception. How does each response change the perception of the player?
"They seem genuine" tells the player that there is a degree of trust and sincerity in the goblin's response. In Critical Role, this statement is used most often when the NPC is being honest; it also conveys to the player (with the second statement also taken into consideration) that it is unlikely that the DM made any rolls for Deception.
"They're hard to read" meanwhile tells another story. It enforces the initial feeling of skepticism and distrust, as it provides neither proof of a lie nor the comfort of knowing the NPC is being honest. It tells the player that this NPC shouldn't be trusted, that they have something to hide.
There is nothing wrong with either response, but I think they are good examples for DMs that want an idea of how information can be conveyed to players in a way that both informs them of information their character doesn't know and misleads players into making assumptions their characters would not reach.
The truth-detecting nature of Insight is definitely a useful tool, but it is also one that I think undersells the potential of the skill. It turns spells like zone of truth and creature abilities like Divine Awareness into less interesting options for DMs and players alike, given that both can be achieved through high and frequent enough Insight checks. In addition, it causes players and DMs to disregard the other potential uses of a body-language skill: detecting comfort level, emotional state, assertiveness, whether they're concealing items on their person – all information that is arguably just as useful, if not more so, than whether they are trying to verbally screw with you!
No comments:
Post a Comment